Blog Layout

At Home with Gary: Welcome mat or “No Pets”: HOAs struggle with support and service dogs

Gary Lanham • Oct 31, 2022

Dogs have gotten a bad rap lately. So have condominium HOAs struggling to enforce their rules. Can’t the two just get along?



In the “emotional support” era, some dog owners have paid for the paperwork from a licensed mental health professional or doctor needed to make their canine a comfort or emotional support animal (ESA). The numbers skyrocketed, from about 2,500 in 2011 to more than 200,000 in 2019.


For people with mental illness, anxiety, loneliness or other bonafide needs, the therapeutic benefits of an ESA can be invaluable. Service animals, conversely, are trained to mitigate a disability or physical or mental impairment that limits a major life activity.

People throw around the terms “comfort” and “service” like they are interchangeable. They are not.


The continued proliferation of ESAs has led to conflicts in “no pet” buildings. Many HOAs have been strong-armed by new buyers or tenants with ESAs demanding to be allowed to buy or rent there. Some successfully have challenged the policies, often under the threat of litigation, to the point that the HOAs have rolled over, rather than fight costly lawsuits.


Many original condo purchasers, however, bought in “no pet” buildings because they wanted peace and quiet.


How can the HOA curb this practice, without running afoul of federal law?


True service animals fall under accommodations found in the Americans with Disabilities Act and the Fair Housing Act; their access to particular places of business, like a restaurant, airport or airliner, could be also governed by other state or federal agencies.


The Fair Housing Act defines assistance animals as those “that work, assist, or perform tasks for the benefit of a person with a disability, including providing emotional support, which alleviates or improves the symptoms or effects of a disability.” The ADA defines service animals as “individual dogs that have been specifically trained to work with or perform specific tasks for people with disabilities including a physical, sensory, psychiatric, intellectual, or other mental disability.


“A psychiatric service dog is not the same thing as an emotional support animal,” the ADA continues, “psychiatric service dogs are trained to detect the onset of psychiatric episodes, which can ultimately lessen the effects of the episodes.”


The Fair Housing Act applies to rentals and condo owners; the ADA applies to hotels and other temporary housing, and buildings used for religious and private functions.


Dawn Hanna, owner of Oh Behave Dog Training in Fort Lauderdale, said part of the issue could be in training. People brought home “pandemic puppies” during Covid or on a whim. Sometime after its arrival, the promise to train the dog to set boundaries and to be a good neighbor was lost. They’re left with a dog that may be antisocial or have anxiety, is dog-aggressive, an incessant barker or a marker of territory. In many situations, a dog that needs more exercise and interaction than life in a highrise allows is left with its basic needs ignored.


A service animal must be under the control of the handler. Most ethical service dog trainers will not even address training the task to mitigate the disability until the dog passes a public access test. It’s an expensive process. To learn more, visit disabilityrightsflorida.org and search for “service animal.”


If you’re an HOA or property owner, how can you ensure a dog is what the owner says it is? You can ask if the dog is a service animal, and what services it is trained to perform, especially if the disability isn’t obvious. You cannot ask about the owner’s disability or for documentation.


Neither I nor Hanna are offering legal advice here. Whether you’re a pet owner, or a property owner or HOA, consult an attorney. If your HOA is having difficulties here, Hanna’s website has a blog explaining these classifications.


As team leader for the Gary Lanham Group at Coldwell Banker Real Estate Fort Lauderdale Beach Office, Gary Lanham is a veteran listing agent skilled in the most complex transactions. ​He knows how to get sellers the most money in the shortest amount of time, even in this changing market. Contact him at instagram.com/garylanhamgroup or call 954-695-6518.

By Gary Lanham 01 May, 2023
By Gary Lanham | Contributing Columnist The past several years have been interesting times for the Fort Lauderdale home sales market. As we’ve explored together in this column, the boom times of too many buyers chasing too few homes, and then, how rising interest and mortgage rates cooled what had been one of Florida’s hottest
By Gary Lanham 03 Apr, 2023
Studies report that the vast majority of home buyers (97 percent) first see online - whether with their smartphone, tablet or computer - the home they eventually purchase. [Courtesy] By Gary Lanham | Contributing Columnist In recent columns, we’ve discussed the importance of “digital curb appeal.” That is, using tools like digital photography, videography and
By Gary Lanham 28 Feb, 2023
Remove furniture that may clutter the home - and open the space to make it more airy. This gives the buyer a chance to visualize the space with their own furniture in it. However, we suggest never emptying a home of all furniture; buyers need a spatial perspective to see how a dining room table
By Gary Lanham 01 Feb, 2023
A major national magazine recently asked me about the definition and importance of digital curb appeal. My short answer was that it’s the way the overwhelming majority of home buyers start reviewing properties for sale. In fact, my answer understated the impact digital curb appeal has today. Digital marketing in real estate takes first impressions to a higher level (another level), don’t miss this opportunity. Whether on their smartphone, tablet or personal computer, about 97 percent of today’s home buyers are first attracted to properties online. As the internet and social media become the way many prospective home buyers see properties of interest, it’s critical that your home shines online. We all know traditional curb appeal. It’s the view of the house from the street, sidewalk or curb out front. Don’t think curb only means single-family residence. Condominiums, townhomes and duplexes also can benefit from digital curb appeal. How is digital curb appeal accomplished? Experienced listing agents encourage sellers to apply fresh paint to their house, or paint a contrast color on the front door. They’re told to manicure the lawn and garden to improve the home’s general attractiveness. This is all outside the home; it has nothing to do with the home’s interior. As buyers drive through the neighborhood, often on the weekends, what stands out are the houses that look like the place they would want to call home. It becomes the invitation to prospective buyers to “see more.” Digital curb appeal takes that presentation a step further to present the entire home to the world – from outside to inside the front door. When we list a home, we hire professional photographers, videographers, even drone operators, to capture the home in the best light. I mean that literally, as photography is shot when the sun shines best on the property. Areas of the home – the kitchen or bathrooms or the pool and patio deck – that have been upgraded or are especially alluring get special attention. This appeal translates to a warmth and charm the home radiates to the viewer. Tech-savvy realtors also routinely provide 3D tours, such as those provided by Matterport, EyeSpy360 or Cupix to show the home as if the viewer were walking through it themselves. How is that viewer found? Realtors versed in digital marketing work in concert with leading SEO partners who use keywords and phrases meant to elevate the property and specific community or neighborhood. We write engaging copy, full of rich details to tell the story of the home, the neighborhood and the lifestyle that could be enjoyed by the buyer. The result is that digital curb appeal allows buyers to “drive” the internet anytime, 24/7 to find properties of interest that coincide with their living/lifestyle requirements. Think of it as a vetting process; they have an earlier opportunity to review the exterior and interior of a house. They can learn about neighborhood assets – parks, restaurants, schools, churches, retailers, even hospitals. The buyers then can take a list of homes or neighborhoods they’ve discovered to their realtor to help guide the search. “This is what I like,” they can advise. “But don’t spend time looking at this area.” That’s why the listing agent must capture the attention of prospective buyers browsing through hundreds of listings. This digital curb appeal becomes the seller’s online chance to make that critical first impression. This is the first in a series of articles exploring the importance of presenting your home online. The next article will explore the strategy behind staging the home and shooting the best photographs and videos unique to the given property. As team leader for the Gary Lanham Group at Coldwell Banker Real Estate Fort Lauderdale Beach Office, Gary Lanham is a veteran listing agent skilled in the most complex transactions. ​He knows how to get sellers the most money in the shortest amount of time, even in this changing market. See Gary’s digital promotions of his listing and contact him at instagram.com/garylanhamgroup or call 954-695-6518 .
By Gary Lanham 03 Jan, 2023
If the COVID and post-COVID era made for interesting times, 2023 promises to be just as challenging – or exciting – depending on your tolerance for the unknown. Below are 12 predictions for the year ahead . . . 1. Home prices will hold in 2023. A shortage of homes in South Florida, combined with homes still selling at record levels, translates to strong pricing. Home prices will go up 3 to 4 percent because of low inventory. While people overpaid for homes in the last two years just to get in, home buying will be an even smarter call in the year ahead than during COVID. 2. Home inventory will shrink. The dilemma of Florida homeowners has been clear: if I sell, where am I going to move? Only homeowners forced to sell due to life events – divorce, death, recession and unemployment – will be motivated to sell. Others will stay put, putting downward pressure on inventory. 3. Foreign investors return to Florida. Political and economic instability and uncertainty across Latin America will continue to drive a flight of capital to the U.S., and particularly South Florida. Lenders flush with money will be eager to loan, meeting the needs of those foreign nationals looking for mortgages. 4. Fix-and-flip home activity will slow down in 2023. The high cost of real estate, coupled with inflation and ongoing supply chain issues, will take these investors out of the market as profitability decreases. 5. Mortgage Interest rates will drop. It’s curious how sometimes when the Fed raises the Federal Reserve rate, mortgage rates may drop. After unprecedented rate hikes over the past year, the Fed has indicated rate increases will slow in 2023. These will end up in the 5 percent range by the end of the year, calming borrower concerns and driving buyer enthusiasm. 6. The number of real estate transactions will go down. The year 2022 saw up to 25 percent fewer real estate transactions than 2021. The year 2023 will have even fewer real estate sales than 2022, as the market finds equilibrium. 7. Rental demand will grow. Fewer real estate transactions and low inventory for sale will fuel growing rental demand. This will cause further increases in rental rates, which are forecast to rise by up to 13 percent for the year. The interest on rent is 100 percent, meaning that you get nothing for your rent. You pay your landlord’s mortgage and, at the end of your rental term, you own nothing . . . so you might as well be paying 100 percent interest. 8. Investment properties will return to the market. These properties, especially Airbnb and other rental properties, will start to hit the market as investors recognize lower returns due to increased supply and lower short-term rental rates, as well as higher taxes and insurance premiums on non-homesteaded properties, and as consumers grow more cautious about their expenses in a questionable economy. 9. Fewer first-time home buyers. High home prices, coupled with increased interest rates, and again, economic uncertainty surrounding their budgets and income, will dampen buyer enthusiasm. Those first-time home buyers who do decide to buy will be pushed to less desirable areas. 10. Seller concessions will grow. The days of “as-is” home sales and waived inspections are over. Fewer buyers, coupled with higher inventory, will induce seller concessions, such as inspection-report repairs, purchase of mortgage rate buy downs, and other creative ways to stand out against other real estate listings. Buyers don’t care about the interest rate or the sales price; the buyers care about their monthly payment. 11. Seniors 62 or older will seek creative cash flow. Seeking a better, more stable retirement, seniors will explore ways to eliminate mortgage payments, increase cash flow and leverage their current residence to live in the home of their dreams through reverse mortgages or other options. 12. Say goodbye to Fort Lauderdale’s older homeowners. Seniors and retirees tired of the region’s congestion – and hoping to capitalize on home values – will cash out and move north. They’ll stay in Florida, but head to places like Stuart, Port St. Lucie, Vero Beach and The Villages. If you’re hoping to list and sell your home, the right realtor can help. As team leader for the Gary Lanham Group at Coldwell Banker Real Estate Fort Lauderdale Beach Office, Gary is a veteran listing agent skilled in the most complex transactions. ​He helps sellers get the most money in the shortest amount of time. Contact him at instagram.com/garylanhamgroup or 954-695-6518 .
By Gary Lanham 08 Dec, 2022
By Gary Lanham Group | Contributing Columnist Those hoping to immigrate to the U.S. have limited options. Those with means can do so through real estate, business investments, or business investments comprising real estate. They invest a fixed amount of money into a business entity that guarantees the creation of a certain number of full-time
By Gary Lanham 31 Oct, 2022
By Gary Lanham | Contributing Columnist Selling a home in today’s market takes creativity, collaboration, and commitment. In the course of a few months, fast-rising interest rates and fears of inflation have halted bidding wars and over-asking-price deals. If you’re looking to sell a home or condominium, how can you stay calm while luring a
By Gary Lanham 08 Oct, 2022
By Gary Lanham | Contributing Columnist If you’re trying to sell or buy a home in today’s real estate market, the Chinese proverb, “May you live in interesting times,” may come off as a curse. The bidding wars and over-asking-price sales of just a few months ago are gone. With inflation on the rise, the
By Gary Lanham 08 Oct, 2022
It’s getting cold in the Sunshine State. Buyers with homes under contract are getting cold feet, and Florida had four of the nation’s top 10 markets with the highest cancellation rates in the past three months, according to CNBC.  Rising interest rates, still-high home prices and uncertainty about the economy have buyers thinking twice about inking the contract or closing the deal. Yet in Fort Lauderdale, including Wilton Manors, Oakland Park and Pompano Beach, listings have increased. If you’re a home seller, what creative incentives can you offer to improve your chances for a sale? Consider the 2-1 buy down . This seller incentive can help lower the interest rate during the first two years by the seller agreeing to “pay points,” or award the buyer a certain number of percentage points of the sales price, which will, in turn, be paid to the buyer’s lender as discount points that bring the buyer’s interest rate down. Rates revert to the contracted rate for year three and for the duration of the loan. If they sell the home, any leftover buy down money reduces the principal; it is not lost like if the mortgagee paid points to reduce the rate permanently. This incentive decreases the pressure buyers feel to guess the right day to lock in their interest rate [a common source of serious stress among buyers] and sends the message that if they buy your home, they’ll automatically beat the market rate. Seller-paid points are usually tax deductible to the buyer. Closing cost credit . Many buyers trying to break into the market while prices are low are already scraping the bottom of their savings account barrels to come up with their down payment money. With most home loans, the buyer will have to come with anywhere from 3 to 6 percent of the loan amount, in cash, on top of their down payment, to cover closing costs like loan fees, escrow services and title or mortgage insurance. Some sellers [and their agents] include in their home’s listing and marketing materials the offer to pay a credit from 3 percent to 6 percent of the home’s sale price at closing to defray the buyer’s closing costs. Turn requested repairs into improvements . By showing repairs to the air conditioner or roof as improvements or offering a home warranty or applying an allowance for such repairs at closing, you’ll boost buyer confidence and help them win over their lender. HOA dues credit . If you are selling a home in a homeowners’ association [HOA] that charges monthly or annual dues, paying those for the six to 12 months or more can help defray significant costs for the buyer. Talk with your agent about how to do this in a way that will offer the maximum lure for buyers but will not run afoul of any guidelines for seller credits imposed by the buyer’s lender. Then, find a realtor who is as eager as you. Will they offer perks like lunches and cash giveaways from a drawing with business cards from open house attendees; partner with another brokerage who has a listing near or in the same neighborhood – and perhaps split the expense by one house offering cash give away for attending; or connect with realtors who have had recent sales in the neighborhood to bring the house to their attention? Will they change up the MLS entry data, or allow any broker to advertise their listing, or increase the commission to the buyer’s agent from 3 percent to 4 percent? These incentives can create an audience for any brokerage where you can assure those agents that you have a property that can compete effectively. If you’re eager to sell your home, the right incentives from you and your agent can prove you’re serious – and win over your buyer. Click here for Part I. As team leader for the Gary Lanham Group at Coldwell Banker Real Estate Fort Lauderdale Beach Office, Gary is a veteran listing agent skilled in the most complex transactions. He knows how to get sellers the most money in the shortest amount of time, even in this changing market. Contact him at instagram.com/garylanhamgroup or call 954-695-6518 . Gary Lanham is a New Pelican advertiser.
By Gary Lanham 06 Sep, 2022
“Think of the tax dollars” As we celebrate 30 years of surviving Hurricane Andrew, Broward County Commissioner Tim Ryan, in another viewpoint, has a good idea concerning the need for a Broward County Mayor. I bring in Andrew because the media that descended upon South Florida did not know who to grab for a sound
More Posts
Share by: